DOCUMENTI GEOGRAFICI - N. 2 (2021)

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Mono-thema: Geografie per l'Ambiente

-

Le “Geografie per l’ambiente” uniscono, nella teoria e nella prassi, i temi propri dell’attuale dibattito scientifico in materia ambientale a scala globale e locale; temi trattati in questo numero di Documenti Geografici con i principi e gli approcci metodologici di quelle scienze che si occupano di ambiente.

-

Atmosfere come indicatori socio-ecologici. – Lo stato ecologico della natura sta sempre più diventando un problema esistenziale per l’uomo. Sebbene la conoscenza disponibile sulla natura si stia ampliando, la capacità di giudizio non sta aumentando della stessa misura. Tra l’altro, spetta alla ragione mediare tra il sentimento e la razionalità. Perché questo accada, tuttavia, i sentimenti devono essere presi seriamente in considerazione a livello sociale, poiché attraverso i sentimenti le atmosfere permettono agli uomini di sentire proprio-corporalmente (leiblich) in quale situazione essi si trovano. L’esempio della catastrofe nucleare di Chernobyl illustra la diversità delle possibili atmosfere che fuoriescono e si “irradiano” da un disastro. Vengono analizzate cinque diverse atmosfere in relazione alla loro funzione. L’esempio mostra anche come gli stati d’animo (Stimmungen) influenzano le atmosfere, ponendole al servizio dell’ideologia. La comunicazione atmosferica della fusione del reattore non porta alla riflessione critica, ma al livellamento ideologico e al marketing turistico di un “evento”.

-

Environmental sustainability among socio-economic variables of influence and geographical determinisms. An analysis of the Italian scenario at nuts-3 level. – The process of awareness of the value of environmental sustainability is currently changing, also due to the the media lever that has catalyzed its dynamics both individually and collectively ones. At a European level, particularly, with the von der Leyen presidency, the orientations based on a vision linked to the Green Deal seem to have strengthened even more, according to which Europe must aim to become the first continent with zero climate impact by 2050, at the same time stimulating the economy, improving people’s health and quality of life, taking care of nature and in the absence of geographical differentials. The real effectiveness of these actions, however, will only materialize where integrated approaches will be adopted able to improve other variables directly related to the propensity for environmental sustainability. The present contribution, through a multivariate regressive analysis, a clustering methodology and the related cartographic representation, therefore tries to understand which are, in the Italian scenario (Nuts 3 scale), these socio-economic variables of possible influence, in order to clarify the territorial differentials that can be detected in the domain of sustainability.

-

When conflict is not seen. Resilience/resistance and territorial hegemony in the forest territories of Chile. – The central-southern regions of Chile have undergone a socio-ecological reterritorialization in the last forty years due to the conformation of an industrial forest monoculture, associated with a forestry sector structured in an oligopoly, dominated by two holding companies. This paper analyses the territorial relations between the wine sector and the forestry sector in the Itata River Valley sub-region. Wine-growing was born in this territory in Chile in the 17th century and has consolidated over time, becoming a reference point on a national scale. In recent decades it has been subjected to various shocks: from changes in wine-making processes to forest expansion. The results of the research lead us to think of socio-ecological relations in terms of a territorial hegemony operated by the main forest societies in economic, cultural and political terms. In cases where they come into contact with productive activities which are “resilient” to this expansion, such as wine-growing, forestry companies adopt practices of co-optation, favoured by the strength derived from the dimension of multinational holding.

-

The territorial needs, the UN 2030 Agenda and the university degree curricula. – In the complex frame of current changes and challenges, the paper aims at presenting the strategies and actions that the University of Piemonte Orientale is addressing to improve its training offer on the sustainability and environmental themes. Interdisciplinarity, territorial involvement, experiential learning are considered key factors to allow the shifting processes and projects towards sustainability on various levels, from civil society to the industrial context, from high schools to the non-profit and third sector.

-

Considerations on the regional landscape plan of Sardinia: a contribution from internal areas. – The concept of landscape is at the core of many geographical studies and is rich in different meanings that over time have given rise to numerous interpretations. According to the European Landscape Convention adopted by the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe in 2000, landscape is a combination of natural and cultural elements in continuous transformation. Transformations that, if not planned attentively, can give rise to processes of deterioration and loss of quality of landscape configurations. In a Europe where there is still a significant dualism between urbanized and rural areas and in an environmental, economic and social era marked by the objectives of sustainability dictated by the 2030 Agenda, it is therefore necessary to adopt and strengthen policies and strategies for a more cohesive development and planning of the territory. The contribution, after a brief review of the literature on European and national policies on the landscape, wants to focus on the ability of regional realities to activate reconstructive interventions and environmental improvements from the adoption of Landscape Plans. In particular, the attention wants to focus on the Sardinian regional context, the first reality in Italy to have adopted a Landscape Plan in 2006. A plan that, to date, has identified only in the coastal areas the areas to be protected and enhanced. However, in the light of the priorities for a sustainable future, the Plan needs to be reviewed and a new plan that can also include the internal areas that are still not sufficiently integrated in the development process of the island.

-

Conflicts over the land-use of the Gaeta coastal zone (southern Lazio, Italy). – The aim of this contribution is to highlight the conflicts that have arisen over the centuries on Gaeta coastal zone in southern Lazio. The conformation of the Gulf, in which it faces, has favoured its vocation of mooring and therefore of maritime activities since ancient times. However, its defence capacity soon made it impregnable to attack by sea, making it a military fortress, so they interrupted its reputation as a commercial port and refuge for vessel. Fortunately, just outside the fortress, a fishing activity and a shipbuilding industry continued to be. These activities relaunched Gaeta until after the Second World War, and still survive today waiting for a new revival. The destruction of the historic walls also rehabilitated that part of the city that was enclosed there, but in it there are also the NATO fleet support and the military vessels controlling and safeguarding the coast of the entire gulf. Meanwhile, in the last decades, Gaeta has regained the role that had belonged since Roman times to a holiday resort. In the summer months, a large number of tourists pour out, especially on the different beaches that are developed on the coast just off the gulf. Over time, bathing, refreshment and accommodation services have been provided to them, threatening valuable coastal habitats, protected by both the Region and the 2000 Nature Network. This relationship between nature and man can be balanced only if the conditions of co-existence are known and respected. Similarly, it can be said for the maritime activities that develop in the Gulf of Gaeta.

-

The management of marine and coastal protected areas in Tunisia. – This contribution will examine the marine environment protection policies which have resulted from the international to endeavours undertaken by Tunisia in the last decade of the twentieth century, thus leading to the recovery of coastal wetlands, the establishment of sensitive coastal zones and Marine and Coastal Protected Areas (AMCP). In particular, when focusing on the latter, it was highlighted that, although specific legislation was issued (2009) following the acknowledgement of international guidelines on a participated management of such areas, the delay with which the implementing decrees (2014) were enacted and the strong existing contradictions within a country that only in recent years has initiated a process of territorial decentralization - a fundamental step for the democratization of the country - have hindered the civil society participation in the management of AMCPs.

-

Fast mapping of the avalanche tracks on the Southern side of Malacoste (Gran Sasso Range, Abruzzi) for a better knowledge of environmental risk. – This note shows the results of a research, conducted in the Gran Sasso area, on the risk of avalanches and related territorial consequences. The study is based on a geological and geographic approach and uses techniques of fast mapping and field research. It was possible to identify the traces of 85 events that occurred between 2007 and 2017, which are many more than those officially registered. This made it possible to specify, at least for the type of wet-snow avalanches, the areas most subject to the phenomenon and highlighted the environmental risks and possible dangers for the visitors in the area. Therefore, it provided useful indications for a more prudent management of risk and better territorial planning.

-

The hydrogeological risk in Calabria in the relocation of Cavallerizzo (Northern Calabria, Italy). – In Italy, there are many areas in hydrogeological instability and many others show clear signs that, added to neglect, poor maintenance, absence of maintenance works and unsustainable territorialization processes, turn into critical issues. Risk mitigation interventions vary depending on the exposure, but even more so on the availability of resources and the perception of risk by the communities involved. About one third of the population lives in these areas with a high hydro-geological risk, which see the relocation of settlements with the consequent abandonment of unstable historical centers among the most complex and controversial interventions. The case study concerns the relocation of the Cavallerizzo di Cerzeto hamlet in Calabria, affected by a deep gravitational movement in the area of more recent urbanization and chosen as it was rebuilt with the urban structure and neighborhood relations of the old village as a settlement for the minority ethnic-linguistic arbëreshe. 

-

Dynamics of the urban forest. The case of Nervi and Sant’Ilario (Genoa). – The text was developed within the PRIN project “Sylva – Ripensare la selva” and aims to analyze some landscape and environmental impacts of the rewilding process that took place in the Nervi valley. Nervi and Sant’Ilario today represent one of the “greenest” areas of the municipality of Genoa. In the past, these localities, favored by a particularly mild microclimate, were however widely exploited for agriculture on terraces and pastoralism. The abandonment process that began in the second half of the twentieth century favored the advance of the forest, interrupted only by the repeated fires that hit the valley. These phenomena have also accentuated the susceptibility to instability of the slopes, demonstrating that reforestation processes are not always positive.

 

-

Functions and benefits of green infrastructure: from contrast to climate change to the tourist positioning of cities. – Cities, in addition to being the main protagonists of global competition, represent those territorial contexts in which the effects of climate change become more evident. Among the sustainable urban planning tools supporting them are green infrastructures that can provide useful solutions capable of strengthening their resilience, transforming them into more pleasant and liveable environments. In light of these considerations, the contribution addresses the role played by green infrastructures also for the purposes of a more effective tourist positioning of cities in compliance with the sustainable development goals.

 

-

The valorization of the natural and cultural heritage of the territory of Grassano and Grottole in Basilicata for sustainable tourism: geomorphological and GIS analysis for planning sustainable tourism itineraries. – The recognition of Matera as European Capital of Culture 2019 will certainly serve in the near future to channel more effectively part of the tourist flow towards the inner areas. Therefore, a study of a significant portion of the inner area of Matera was undertaken, aimed at collecting elements of the physical landscape that would act as a landscape “frame” for the formulation of hypotheses of routes with “multiple” values. In fact, the study area includes the villages of Grassano and Grottole, which have elements of cultural interest that are useful for valorising the itinerary to be proposed. The knowledge of the geographical elements of the study area, the accurate analysis of the forms of the physical landscape and the geomorphological processes that have generated them, the inventory of the main cultural attractions of the two villages located in the study area, as well as the use of a geographical information system, have made it possible to design the route proposed in this article.

-

Campi Flegrei: nature and culture. Landscape, risk and everyday life. – The Campi Flegrei are an area of volcanic origin, located north of Naples, where geological events and eruptions have upset the geography of this territory/physical-chemical laboratory. The area has been a favorite place for anthropic settlement since ancient times: the strong presence of sulfur and nitrogen have made the Phlegraean soil very fertile and the presence of the sea makes the climate mild. The Phlegraean territory has welcomed famous Greek colonies and Roman centers of primary importance, such as Cuma, Dicearchia / Puteoli, Baia, Miseno and large modern manufacturing settlements. I intend to analyze the landscape results that have been created and perceived, trying to investigate the particular relationship between physical geography and human geography that has been formed in this territory, together with the considerations that emerge in relation to the risk that the Phlegraean community experiences daily and social vulnerability and environmental peculiar to the area. 

-

Gli impatti ambientali delle attività sportive. Le buone pratiche di sostenibilità. Il caso del golf. – Lo studio intende evidenziare l’intensa e difficile relazione tra sport e ambiente prendendo in esame il caso del golf, uno sport che richiede una pianificazione e gestione dei percorsi più attenta e consapevole degli impatti ambientali, non solo per fronteggiare le pressioni esterne esercitate da coloro che denunciano gli effetti negativi sull’ambiente del golf, ma anche per ragioni economiche e pratiche di gioco. Efficienza energetica e uso di fonti rinnovabili, risparmio idrico, riduzione di prodotti chimici, limitazione dei rifiuti; conservazione della biodiversità; sensibilizzazione del pubblico sono obiettivi determinanti per l’affermazione dello sport sostenibile, una dimensione che esige, da un lato, l’impegno delle organizzazioni sportive, dei responsabili di eventi e di tutti gli stakeholder a vario titolo coinvolti di perseguire dette finalità e, dall’altro, un costante interesse e sostegno della ricerca scientifica per promuovere nuove conoscenze e comprendere le dinamiche del rapporto tra sport e ambiente.

-

New perspectives on Covid-19 and epistemic injustices. – The Covid-19 outbreak is often associated with pollution and overexploitation of common global resources. Less attention, though with a few exceptions, has been paid to the social and human origins of the crisis. In fact, asymmetric power relations among social groups can determine the outbreak of crises and a reallocation of their related risks towards social and territorial peripheries. Research shows how the concept of epistemic injustice can take on systemic connotations, as the use of inappropriate or ineffective analytic tools can lead to practices that are perceived as just, effective, or efficient, but in fact lack these requirements. The negative impacts of such an eventuality would far outweigh the mitigating effect and magnitude of the ongoing redistribution processes and may fuel increasingly unequal power relations between insiders and outsiders. In this scenario, the rediscovery of an ethic of the common good is an essential element in the design and implementation of a collective way out of the crisis.

-

Environmental impact and industry: the case of the cement-based plants of Colleferro and Guidonia. – Colleferro and Guidonia are two Lazio municipalities of the metropolitan city of Roma Capitale, linked to an industrial vocation, in particular that of cement. The first with the Italcementi pozzolana company, the other with the Buzzi Unicem cement plant. They are important factories because of the effects on local employment and economy. The two cement plants have adopted the best technologies available in favor of the environment and health, effectively reducing the production of polluting dust and CO2, but a more accurate study of the health evidence produced over time is needed.This case study can provide useful qualitative-quantitative indicators concerning the complex industry-environment-health relationship in two different contexts, even if they fall within the same regional reality.

-

Biofuels and bioplastics between opportunities and opportunisms in a regional experience. – Global and European strategies on renewable energies increasingly highlight the need for a paradigm shift in socio-spatial relations in agriculture. The territoriality of the renewable energy supply chains re-proposes the top-down characteristics of the fossil fuels era, deferring the support to coherent initiatives linking energy and territorial systems. The contribution explores European biomass strategies and their effects on a territorial level in Sardinia. The EU and Italian government strategies aiming at consolidating bioenergy and bioplastic production, both in terms of regulatory regulation and financial incentives for production, are reviewed. Starting from the agriculture and biomass energy production literature and based on a series of interviews carried out between 2018 and 2020 with local stakeholders, the effects of policies are investigated. The energy production process from biomass in Sardinia and the internal and external variables connected to it are examined.

-

The wind farm as a symbolic landscape. – Wind energy has had a remarkable development in Italy in recent years, despite severe criticism on the environmental and social impact of the plants. In particular, numerous studies and research have been conducted on the subject of the visual impact of wind turbines, mostly giving space to those who consider them a territorial realization that disfigures the landscape. The widespread construction of what today in Italy are commonly called wind parks must however lead us to consider that just as many are those who see in the plants not so much an element of visual disturbance but, on the contrary, an element of the landscape with an acceptable aesthetic value, and in some cases even positive. The research focuses on two wind farms – Monte d’Aria in Marche and Cinque Stelle in Liguria – close to established Italian tourist regions with the primary aim of giving a voice to those who, residents or tourists, consider them symbol and flag of a new, correct approach of society towards the natural environment.

-

Verso un urbanismo a rifiuti zero: un manifesto per un futuro sostenibile. – Le città sono il principale luogo di produzione e consumo di rifiuti, nonché di rapida urbanizzazione. Questo articolo prende in considerazione la tradizione rifiuti zero, guardando in particolare alle città rifiuti zero, e mettendola in dialogo con le tradizioni critiche, in particolare con l’ecologia politica urbana. L’urbanismo rifiuti zero viene presentato come una nuova prospettiva e un invito all’azione, non solo per progettare città migliori, ma anche per cambiare la società e rielaborare i sistemi politici. Ponendo le sue domande chiave quelle che interrogano il potere, l’urbanismo rifiuti zero radicalizza l’approccio rifiuti zero, sviluppando nuovi modi di esplorare la realtà proponendo una visione ricostruttiva per creare futuri urbani sostenibili. In tal modo, questo lavoro mira a raggiungere sia i professionisti di rifiuti zero, sia i ricercatori interdisciplinari che gli attivisti-ricercatori.

-

Climate Changes and International Security. – «Global warming is potentially the most dangerous of all forms of terrorism»: this is the disturbing revelation of a report prepared for the Pentagon by two American futurists, Peter Schwartz and Doug Randall. All that might be caused by climate changes as result of accumulation of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere: the first to be hit would be, the Gulf Stream, which for centuries mitigates the climate of the east coast of the United States and northern Europe with a later «domino devastating effect». The report, which was to be secret, was for 2004 but was later published by various media organizations. Today, these positions are becoming increasingly important. On June 5, 2009, the United Nations General Assembly adopted a resolution recognizing that global warming may cause a threat to international security and calling for UN agencies to «intensify efforts» to combat the effect emissions. But there are also dissenting voices.

-

Anthropocene and geography. – The concept of Anthropocene is used today in many disciplinary sectors to thematize the issues concerning the enormous and growing impact of human activities on nature. His introduction in the field of geographic studies has placed at the center the reflection on the heart of geographic epistemology: the relationships between human societies and the environment, their ecological consequences, the interpretation of the landscape, the analysis and the critical deconstruction of representations, the relationship between physical and human geography in scientific investigation. The article discusses the contribution of geographers to research on the Anthropocene and presents some ideas on the role that geography can play in scientific research on the Anthropocene. On the one hand, geography can support the critical reading of the ways in which the Anthropocene has also become a concept widely used by the media, contextualizing and deconstructing narratives. On the other hand, also by using the potential of thematic cartography in visualizing data and allowing reflections and analyzes at different scales, helping to territorialize the Anthropocene narrative, highlighting the changes and processes in the different regions of the planet.

-

Environmental transition and energy transition. A regional analysis – The relationship between environmental quality and GDP has been emphasized in the past, placing the accent on the “natural” trend towards improving environmental quality during the maturity of economic growth, after its deterioration in “takeoff” phases of the economy, according the socalled Environmental Kuznets Curve (EKC). This condition has in many parts been disavowed or weakened. In the same way, an attempt was made to read the energy transition through the EKC filter, but a regional analysis, carried out within the European Union, of the components of the energy transition (energy demand, intensity of energy, consumption of fossil fuels and renewables) shows that these conditions can vary considerably from country to country and that policies can determine changes, not just economic growth.

Poli-thema

-

Economic growth and human development: From “theoretical” reflection to the opportunities of the “NewgenerationEU” plan. – With the publication by Serge Latouche, of “La décroissance” (2006) and even before with “Les dangers du marché planetaire” (1998), the need for a drastic change in the perspective of development followed by the Western world is felt, to be achieved through a clear modification of the fundamental parameters of economic growth. In the years immediately following, a group of scholars coordinated by geographer M.G. Lucia, published in-depth research on the interaction that crosses economy, environment and society in the link between “weak” and “strong” sustainibility. Starting from these bases, the contribution, through a careful survey of the literature on the subject, delves into a topical aspect of the expected process of “ecological transition” according to the geo-economic prospects related to the creation of new job opportunities in the area of the so-called “Good jobs”.

-

Mural maps. Preliminary remarks on the little known case of Villa Mondragone. – Mural maps are a typical tradition of the XVIth Century cartography in the Italian context as symbols of knowledge, power and geopolitical struggle. While the main examples of the “Galleria delle carte geografiche” in Vatican and the “Sala della Cosmografia” in the Palazzo Farnese in Caprarola have been well studied, in the Villa Mondragone, near Rome, there is a later example dated XIX Century which seems to follow the same tradition with different aims. It was the Sala Ciampi, which was part of the Collegium animated by the Jesuits. Nowadays the two mural maps are in very poor conditions, but old postcards remind us how the Sala appeared during the 20’s and 30’s. This contribution represents a first approach in the study of the origins of those maps in the context of the late Renaissance Villa Mondragone, which can emerge other research interests.

-

The view of Popocatepetl in historiographical sources on the conquest of Mexico. – During the Conquest of Mexico (1519-1521), and throughout the time of the Colonial New Spain, the Spanish were amazed by the Popocatepetl. This paper aims at analyzing the paragraphs which historical sources (XVI and XVII centuries) devoted to several aspects of the volcano, including what is believed to be the first ascent. According to the Spanish sources, the volcano constrained the maneuvers of conquistadores, but they managed to understand its nature. From the viewpoint of the natives, the mountain was primarily a metaphysical constraint, which symbolized the gateway to hell. Other authors reported the rituals celebrated in the site, which were later attested by archeological studies. The present survey draws from literary, documental and iconographic sources, as well as from the current academic literature.

Agorà (Responsabili Giovanni Mauro, Maria Ronza)

-

Constitution without nature

 

-

The Circular Economy Model in the City and the Territory

-

A slow way of enjoying the landscape: photographic cycle tourism

-

Are urban planning and public participation still necessary in Campania?

-

The geopolitical factor in the formation of a national leading class

Kritiké (Responsabile Daniele Paragano)

-

The glocalism of Tor Bella Monaca peripheral conversations about a city that no longer exists

Because anthropology helps us to do politics (and to live better)

-

G20, Atlante del rischio climatico. Impatti, politica, economia

-

Identity and geopolitics of Europe. The "fourth side" of the triangle Russia, United States, China

-

Public Geography practices. A year with the Italian Touring Club to the rediscovery of geography

-

Geography and geographers in Italy from Unity to the First World War

-

Hyper-places. The new geography of globalization

-

Ai confini

-

22 Glaciologic Itineraries on the Italian Mountains

-

Il Pianeta Cattolico. Una Geografia culturale

-

All roads leave from Rome

-

 

Landscape and Territory